Provincial Voting Records

Candidate, David Birnbaum

Québec Liberal Party, D'Arcy-McGee, QC

Bio

David Birnbaum
Not Supportable
CLC rating: Pro-abortion, pro-LGBT ideology
Rating Comments: In May 2022, this MNA voted for a Motion asserting that woman had a "right" to kill their children by abortion (see Votes tab). Did not seek re-election in the 2022 Quebec provincial race.
First elected (yyyy.mm.dd): 2014.04.07
Previous Occupation: school board director
Birthdate (yyyy.mm.dd): 1956.04.08
Religion / Faith: unknown

Contact

David Birnbaum
Parliamentary Office
Hôtel du Parlement
1045 rue des Parlementaires, 2e étage, Bureau 2.38
Québec , Quebec
G1A 1A3
Tel: 418-528-1960
Constituency Offices
5800, boulevard Cavendish, Bureau 403
Côte-Saint-Luc, Quebec
H4W 2T5
Tel: 514-488-7028
Fax: 514-488-1713

Here is David Birnbaum's voting record relating to life and family issues:

Votes, Surveys and Policy Decision Vote Score
Not Supportable
Bill 52, final reading, To legalize euthanasia giving doctors the power to kill their patients
This dangerous bill violates the Criminal Code of Canada by attempting to legalize the form of homicide known as euthanasia. The Parti Quebecois used verbal gymnastics and euphemism to describe as "health care" an action by a doctor to end the life of his patient. This dangerous, unlawful bill targets the elderly and disabled persons who will face internal and external pressure to consider euthanasia. In essence it will create a 'duty to die' in the minds of many Quebecers. On June 5, 2014, the bill passed 3rd reading by a vote of 94 to 22 with no abstentions. Now it falls on the federal government to block Quebec's unlawful action.
Yes bad
Bill 70, final reading, to criminalize parental, psychotherapeutic & spiritual guidance for unwanted sexual feelings
Vote on taking away the right of people who experience UNWANTED gender identity confusion or homosexual attraction to be able to obtain clinical therapy or pastoral counseling to help them live according to their faith or to overcome the unwanted sexual feelings. This unconstitutional bill also fines parents up to $50,000 for providing body-affirming counselling to their sexually-confused children, or for discouraging a gay lifestyle in contradiction with the family’s religious faith. The totalitarian bill passed Final Reading by a vote of 121 to 0 (unanimous) on December 9, 2020.
Yes bad
Motion to reaffirm the "right" of pregnant mothers to freely kill their unwanted children by abortion.
This Motion, made in Quebec National Assembly in the weeks preceding the anticipated overturning by the U.S. Supreme Court of the pro-abortion 1973 Roe vs. Wade decision, was a toothless gesture of "solidarity" with those who wish prenatal child-killing by abortion to continue unabated, forever. This ghoulish Motion passed by a vote of 93 - 0 on May 3, 2022.
Supported bad

There are no quotes for David Birnbaum at this time.

Here are the answers for the questionnaire as provided by David Birnbaum on 2018.

Question Response
Do you acknowledge that human life begins at conception (fertilization)? not surveyed
Are there any circumstances under which you believe a woman should have access to abortion? (note: Medical treatments to save the life of a mother and which result in the UNINTENDED death of her unborn child, are NOT abortions. Eg. in case of tubal pregnancy or cervical cancer) not surveyed
Will you support measures to stop funding abortions with taxpayers’ money in Quebec? not surveyed
Do you agree women have the right to be thoroughly informed about the serious health consequences of abortion, the development of their child in the womb and the alternatives to abortion? not surveyed
Will you protect the rights of parents to educate their children according to their faith in matters of moral principles and beliefs concerning abortion, contraception and homosexuality? not surveyed
Will you oppose euthanasia and instead support measures to promote “palliative care”, the purpose of which is to alleviate pain, and enhance the quality of life for terminally ill patients and those with disabilities? *Euthanasia is the direct and intentional killing of a person by action or omission, with or without that person’s consent, for what people mistakenly believe are compassionate reasons. not surveyed
Will you support legislation to protect the right of health care workers who refuse to participate in procedures which are in violation of their religious or conscientious beliefs? not surveyed

There are no videos available for David Birnbaum. If you have relevant video from all-candidate meetings or other functions that is not copyrighted by a third party, please send it to us.

  • Legend for Light Rating System
  • Green Light
    GREEN light means the person supports CLC principles and is rated as SUPPORTABLE
  • Red Light
    RED light means the person is NOT SUPPORTABLE
  • Amber Light
    AMBER light means voters should be cautious about the candidate. CLC is still evaluating this individual, does not have enough data, or their record is mixed. View their quotes & voting history to help you decide.