Liberals Unveil Deadly Euthanasia Bill Disguised as ‘Safeguards’

As we reported last month, the Liberals voted down Bill C-218, which would have permanently removed mental illness as a sole qualifying condition for legal euthanasia (MAiD).
Liberal Justice Minister Sean Fraser effectively ensured the bill’s defeat by signalling that Liberal MPs should vote it down because the government intended to introduce its own legislation. That legislation would indefinitely exclude people whose sole underlying condition is a mental illness while simultaneously expanding euthanasia through advance requests for people diagnosed with serious illnesses (such as dementia) who may later lose capacity to consent.
We called this a diabolical ploy intended to trade protection for one group of people for the creation of another killable class of patients. While some pro-life groups took a wait-and-see approach, we opposed the yet-unseen bill because we knew it would be immoral.
On October 27, the Carney Liberals introduced Bill C-41, the Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act. To the extent the bill provides “safeguards,” they largely protect practitioners from prosecution. The language repeatedly requires only that a medical or nurse practitioner be “of the opinion” that the person meets the criteria, making it extremely difficult to hold anyone accountable if the law is not followed.
While the bill permanently blocks "MAiD" where mental illness is the sole underlying condition, its main focus is the legalization of advance requests for people who lose the capacity to consent. Under the bill, once an advance request has been made, a practitioner is not required to inform the person what is about to happen or even speak with them before ending their life. The procedure may proceed solely on the basis of the earlier request, and the practitioner’s assessment that the described symptoms and suffering are present, subject only to a check for what the bill calls “refusal or resistance.” When euthanasia was legalized in 2016, advocates insisted that safeguards would ensure the full and ongoing consent of the person being euthanized. That protection is now being stripped away.
Our National President, Jeff Gunnarson, said about this in a press release: “We now see consent being whittled away when it comes to euthanizing sick people. Where this slippery slope inevitably leads is euthanasia without consent—a horror that is not without historical precedent.”
Euthanasia Prevention Coalition executive director Alex Schadenberg has identified further serious problems with Bill C-41. It does not provide effective oversight of the law; it permits practitioners to claim as a defence that they were of the “opinion” the person met all the criteria; it egregiously permits advance requests; and it expands euthanasia despite the fact that the legislatively required five-year review of the original 2016 law (Bill C-14) was never conducted.
On November 3, as second-reading debate on the bill was already underway in the House, we called on Parliament to split C-41 and pass the mental illness exclusion on its own before March 17, 2027, when the temporary exclusion expires and euthanasia for mental illness as a sole condition would become legal. Conservative MPs have also called for the same thing, but the Liberal government will have nothing to do with it.
On November 17, after only eight hours of debate, the bill passed second reading 225 to 89 and was referred to the Justice Committee. Thirty-seven Conservatives voted in favour and 89 against. MP Andrew Lawton criticized the Liberals’ decision to rush the bill through without proper debate and consultation as “the most cynical and undemocratic form of politics.”
Take Action: Contact your MP and ask them to split Bill C-41 and pass the mental illness exclusion on its own.
Read the entire December 2026 edition of CLC National News online here.
Donate to Campaign Life Coalition by clicking here or the button below.


